Heath Track Australia

Is Private Health Cover Worth It?

Stethoscope
Content Team
A car is parked in front of a medical clinic

Public Healthcare Down Under — What Medicare Covers and What It Doesn’t

Understanding Australia’s universal system before opting in

Australia’s Medicare system is the backbone of our healthcare — it gives Aussie citizens and permanent residents access to free or subsidised treatment in public hospitals, bulk‑billed visits to GPs and specialists, and subsidised pathology and imaging services. It’s fair dinkum: a robust starting point for healthcare coverage. But it doesn’t cover everything.

Think optical, dental, physio and chiro — these extras often fall outside of Medicare’s safety net. Ambulance rides are usually excluded too, except in some states where limited ambulance cover is provided. That’s where private health cover comes in.

Private health policies typically have two main components:
hospital cover and extras cover (sometimes called general treatment). Hospital cover helps with private hospital stays, theatre fees and surgeon costs. Extras cover offers rebates for allied services and allied health practitioners.

Before jumping in, it's vital to weigh what you already get from Medicare and what you actually need. Public hospitals are great for emergency and medically‑necessary care, but if you want choice of surgeon, private hospital room and flexibility around elective procedures, private cover might be worth it.

The Financial Upside — Rebates, Surcharges and Waiting Lists

How private health cover can put more pep in your pocket

For many Aussies, the decision to take out private health cover comes down to money.

First, there’s the Private Health Insurance Rebate. It’s a government subsidy applied as a discount on your premium, based on your income and age. Younger, lower‑income Aussies may get up to around 30 % off, while higher earners receive less. It’s a handy saving that directly lowers your out‑of‑pocket costs.

Next, consider the Lifetime Health Cover (LHC) loading. That’s a penalty for taking out hospital cover after you turn 31. If you delay enrolling, you’ll pay 2 % extra per year until you get covered, for ten years. Commit early, and you avoid paying a premium loading. Get in by age 30, and you’re laughing.

Then there’s the Medicare Levy Surcharge (MLS). If you’re a single earning above roughly $97k, or a couple/family above about $194k, and you don’t hold hospital cover, you pay an extra 1 – 1.5 % in tax. For a $120k earner, that’s easily $1,200 added to your tax bill. Paying for basic hospital cover might actually save you dough in the long run.

CHOICE consumers have done the sums: singles earning over $97k can save by taking out even a basic cover, paying less than the surcharge. But if your income sits beneath the MLS thresholds, or you don’t need private treatment perks, the numbers don’t always stack up.

Annual premium rises — often hovering around 3–6 % — can sting in a cost‑of‑living squeeze. So, while rebates and surcharge avoidance can justify private cover for some, careful comparison and reviewing of your policy is key. It’s not a set‑and‑forget deal.

Personal Considerations — Who Benefits Most?

Matching your health needs with the right cover

It’s not one‑size‑fits‑all. Whether private health is worth it depends on your personal and family situation.

If you expect to need elective surgery — say, knee reconstructions, hernia ops or joint replacements — private cover enables faster access and often better choice of surgeon. Public waiting lists can be long, and if speed’s important, private cover can make a big difference.

Extras cover can deliver strong value too — particularly if you regularly visit a dentist, get glasses or see a physio or chiro. Some plans offer unlimited general dental, optical or physio rebates. A Redditor from Australia summed it up simply: “Private Healthcare (extras) is exceptionally worth it... It’s the unlimited general dental that does it.” For active Aussies who use those services, that added extras cover can significantly offset the cost of premiums.

If your health is relatively stable and you don’t mind public hospital care or waiting lists, you might be better off putting that premium toward savings or super. Many choose to self‑insure — that is, skip private cover and pay for any healthcare out of pocket. It’s a gamble, but sometimes it works out.

For families or couples with moderate incomes, it’s often about striking a balance. Emergencies and childbirth can be smoother in the private system. But unless your needs align, you could be paying for cover you never use.

For high‑income earners, private cover is nearly essential to dodge the MLS. For young Aussies under 30, signing on early avoids future LHC loadings — which can compound. For retirees or those with chronic conditions, private cover can offer peace of mind and privacy with fewer out‑of‑pocket costs from specialists.

Final Verdict — Is It Worth It?

How to make an informed choice

Private health cover can be worth it — but only if it aligns with your circumstances. Here’s a quick checklist to work through:

Start with your family health history and foreseeable needs. Then assess your financial position including income, ability to pay premiums, and your tolerance for risk.

Crunch the numbers — compare premiums with rebate and potential tax savings. Consider the LHC loading if you're past 30. And don’t forget extras — work out if the out‑of‑hospital benefits offset the cost.

Check out reputable comparison tools — Choice, Canstar, Finder — to evaluate policies and find what best fits your needs. Reviewing annually is wise — premiums and personal health needs change.

Remember, public care through Medicare is solid. Private cover is more about comfort, choice and avoiding waiting lines. It’s not a safety net — it’s a luxury, with strings and conditions attached.

Ultimately, private health cover is worth it for many Aussies: those who want faster care, prefer privacy, use allied health services regularly or earn enough to be dinged by tax. For others, public healthcare may suffice — as long as you budget sensibly and stay aware of your health needs.

References